Photo: ChatGPT Plus/CarPro.

News

Suits & Settlements: The Car Pro Legal Roundup

Written By: Jerry Reynolds | Nov 17, 2026, 2:57:06 PM

Editor's note: Suits & Settlements is a weekly column in which Car Pro Show host Jerry Reynolds takes a look at the latest automotive-related legal headlines.

  • Toyota Says Recall and Free Loaners Leave Hybrid Owner With No Case
  • Justice Department Seeks $53 Million From Lyft Over Disability Discrimination
  • Tesla Asks Appeals Court to Erase $243 Million Autopilot Verdict
  • 7-Eleven Accused of Overselling the Benefits of Premium Gasoline

Toyota Says Recall and Free Loaners Leave Hybrid Owner With No Case

Toyota is asking an Illinois federal judge to dismiss a proposed class action involving the inverter recall covering certain 2025 and 2026 Camry Hybrids and 2026 Corolla Cross Hybrids.

Michael Jaffe sued Toyota Motor Sales U.S.A. and Toyota Motor Engineering & Manufacturing North America, alleging the companies knew about an improperly tightened inverter bolt before he purchased his 2026 Camry. The condition prompted a federal recall of 55,405 vehicles because a loose bolt could interrupt the electrical connection, causing a loss of power or, in some circumstances, an electrical short and fire.

Jaffe alleges his new Camry remained at a dealership for months while Toyota developed and completed a repair. He says the delay deprived him of the use and enjoyment of his vehicle and reduced its value, even though Toyota furnished loaner vehicles.

Toyota’s November 11 dismissal motion argues that Jaffe has not alleged a compensable injury because his Camry was repaired at no charge and he received free transportation while it was unavailable. Toyota also contends the recall process adequately addressed the safety condition.

The judge has not ruled on Toyota’s motion, and no class has been certified. Jaffe’s claims that Toyota concealed the problem and owes owners damages remain allegations.

For buyers, the case raises an interesting question: Does a free recall repair and a complimentary loaner make an owner whole after a new vehicle spends months sitting at a dealership? Toyota says yes. The plaintiff says there is more to owning a new car than simply having something else to drive.

Justice Department Seeks $53 Million From Lyft Over Disability Discrimination

The U.S. Department of Justice sued Lyft on November 9, accusing the ride-hailing company and its drivers of repeatedly denying transportation to passengers with disabilities.

The lawsuit, filed in California federal court, alleges violations of the Americans with Disabilities Act involving riders with service dogs, stowable wheelchairs and other mobility devices. The government says some riders were refused service, charged cancellation fees after being denied rides or prevented from sitting in the front seat when their disabilities required it.

One example involves retired federal appellate Judge David Tatel, who is blind and uses a guide dog. According to the complaint, one driver ordered Tatel and his dog out of a vehicle in April 2023. In September 2026, another driver allegedly locked the doors and drove away after seeing Tatel and the dog. These are allegations in the government’s complaint, not findings by a court.

The Justice Department is seeking $53 million for people who allegedly experienced discrimination and submitted complaints to Lyft or the government. It also wants a court order requiring policy changes, employee and driver training, and a civil penalty.

Lyft disputes the allegations. The company reportedly says its policies require drivers to accommodate service animals and mobility devices and that drivers who violate those rules can be permanently removed from the platform.

The case matters because ride-hailing services have become an essential transportation option, particularly for people who cannot drive. A policy in an app means very little if the passenger is still left standing at the curb.

Tesla Asks Appeals Court to Erase $243 Million Autopilot Verdict

Tesla is asking the 11th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals to overturn a $243 million verdict arising from a fatal 2019 crash involving a Model S operating with Autopilot engaged.

Driver George McGee was traveling through Key Largo, Florida, when he looked down to retrieve his cellphone. His Tesla ran through an intersection and struck a Chevrolet Tahoe parked on the roadside, killing 22-year-old Naibel Benavides Leon and seriously injuring her boyfriend, Dillon Angulo.

A federal jury determined that McGee was 67% responsible and Tesla was 33% responsible. It awarded $129 million in total compensatory damages and $200 million in punitive damages, leaving Tesla responsible for approximately $243 million. U.S. District Judge Beth Bloom rejected Tesla’s request to overturn the verdict or order a new trial in February.

Tesla’s appeal argues that McGee’s reckless driving—not a vehicle defect—caused the collision. The company maintains that Autopilot was a driver-assistance feature requiring constant supervision and that no comparable system available in 2019 would have prevented the crash.

The plaintiffs counter that Tesla encouraged drivers to place too much confidence in Autopilot and failed to implement adequate operating and driver-monitoring restrictions. The appeals court has not ruled, and the verdict remains in place while the case is reviewed.

The outcome could influence future litigation involving Level 2 driver-assistance systems. Drivers remain responsible for controlling their vehicles, but this verdict shows that a jury may also hold a manufacturer accountable for how a system is designed, restricted and marketed.

7-Eleven Accused of Overselling the Benefits of Premium Gasoline

A New York woman has filed a proposed class action accusing 7-Eleven of misleading motorists about the benefits of its premium and midgrade gasoline.

The complaint, filed November 13 in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of New York, alleges that the company’s fuel labels lead customers to believe higher-octane gasoline will benefit most vehicles. The plaintiff contends that many motorists paid more for premium or midgrade fuel even though those grades provided little or no additional benefit for vehicles designed to run on regular gasoline.

These are the plaintiff’s allegations. No class has been certified, and no court has determined that 7-Eleven’s pump labels were misleading or that customers are entitled to reimbursement.

For drivers, the practical advice remains simple: Follow the vehicle manufacturer’s fuel recommendation. If the owner’s manual says premium is required, use it. If premium is merely recommended, it may improve performance under some conditions. If the vehicle is designed for regular, buying a higher octane generally does not transform it into a rocket ship—it mostly transforms more money into a gasoline receipt.

The case could matter to fuel retailers if the court finds that familiar terms such as “premium” imply performance or engine benefits that are not adequately explained at the pump.

Photo: ChatGPT Plus/CarPro.

Save up to 60% on Vehicle Protection

Compare the top providers via Chaiz, an Official CarPro Partner.

Jerry Reynolds

“Our listeners know we will always be upfront with them. Partnering with Chaiz means we can connect them with a resource that takes the same honest approach we do.”

"The Car Pro" Jerry Reynolds