I've covered plenty of Federal Trade Commission actions against car dealers in the Car Pro Show newsletter and I usually come away thinking the honest dealers are as glad to see the FTC show up as car buyers are. I felt that way when I was a dealer. If I put a price in an ad that a customer could actually buy the car for, I wanted the store across town to compete on the same terms. So, when I read the FTC's allegations against Stream Auto Outlet, a group of three Long Island, New York, dealerships, I was glad to see the agency take it to court. Then I read the proposed settlement. No fine. No refunds for customers. How is that fair to the people who paid those charges or the dealers who advertised an honest price all along?
What the FTC Says Happened
In its Nov. 9 complaint, the FTC alleged that Stream advertised vehicles online at prices it routinely refused to honor. In one listing cited by the agency, a shopper had to open a pop-up and scroll into the fine print to learn that the advertised price assumed a $3,995 down payment. A down payment is part of the purchase price. If you have to bring another $3,995 to get the advertised deal, the car costs another $3,995. That's an awfully big number to put in awfully small type.
The part that really got my attention was what the FTC says happened after it warned Stream in March about its pricing practices. According to the complaint, the dealerships added the slogan “NO FEES. NO GAMES. JUST CARS.” to their websites. Months after the warning, the FTC alleges, a representative told a shopper the advertised price was the real price and there were no fees. A second representative said a $2,700 LoJack package was required to buy the car. The written quote, according to the FTC, included that charge and more than $1,000 in other charges. Under the proposed settlement, the dealerships neither admit nor deny the pricing allegations.
What the Settlement Would Do
If a federal judge approves the proposed order, it would bar the dealerships from misrepresenting costs and require them to prominently display the full price, including all mandatory dealer charges. Government-required charges such as sales tax could be excluded from that figure. The dealerships would have to keep copies of ads, sales paperwork and complaints and submit a sworn compliance report after a year. The FTC could also check compliance by posing as a customer. Those obligations would be enforceable in court. For a buyer who already paid a charge the FTC says was hidden, the agreement provides no money back.
Why No Fine?
The FTC brought this case under a provision of federal law that lets it go directly to court to stop unlawful conduct. In its 2021 AMG Capital Management decision, the U.S. Supreme Court held that this provision does not let the FTC recover money for consumers. Civil penalties require separate legal authority, and a warning letter alone does not create it. The FTC's announcement gives no case-specific explanation for why the agency pursued an agreement without financial relief.
Here's what that looks like from the other side of the showroom. Suppose one dealer lists a car for $24,000, including every required dealer charge. Another lists a comparable car at $20,000 and waits until the shopper comes in to reveal another $4,000 in mandatory charges. The honest dealer can lose the customer before anyone even makes a phone call. And once a buyer has driven across town, taken a test drive and spent an afternoon at the dealership, plenty of people will finish the deal just to be done with it. The dealer that showed the real price may never get a chance to earn that business.
I want the FTC to stop deceptive advertising as soon as it can. I also want a dealer doing the math on whether to hide a fee to know that getting caught can cost more than the practice brings in. That means getting money back to buyers where the law allows it and imposing meaningful penalties when there's authority to do so. If the FTC lacks the authority it needs to do that in cases like this, Congress ought to give it the tools. The dealers who put the real price in the ad are already doing what the government asks. They deserve a fair shot at the sale.