A Tesla has cracked the top five at our auctions. At SCA Auctions we went through nearly 10,000 of our own sales, and the world's best-selling EV is now outselling the Ford F-150 on our block, often for a third of its retail price.
The Tesla Nobody Saw Coming
For years, an electric car at a mainstream auction was a novelty. Now Tesla ranks fifth overall by nameplate, ahead of the Honda Accord and the Toyota Corolla. The Model 3 leads the brand, with the Model Y close behind.
It lines up with what's happening at the top of the sales charts. In May 2026 the Tesla Model Y was the best-selling EV in the world, and it has been the best-selling car of any kind, globally, for three years running. Cars that sell in those numbers flow straight into the used and auction markets next. The first big waves of EVs are now coming off lease, out of fleets, and back around for a second life, and the auction lane is where they land first.
What A Model Y Costs At Auction vs. The Dealer
Here's where it gets interesting for buyers. On the used market, the Model Y is no longer a luxury purchase, and at auction it's downright accessible.
At a dealer, a comparable used Model Y typically runs in the high‑$20,000s to low‑$30,000s, with 2020–2022 examples often listing from the low‑$20,000s. A brand-new one starts north of $41,000.
At SCA, the numbers look very different. Across the Teslas that sold through our own lanes, the Model Y took a median winning bid of around $11,000. The cheapest was a 2021 Model Y that went for just $7,000. Most of these are recent cars, with a median model year of 2022, and we've even seen 2024, 2025, and 2026 Model Ys roll across our block.
That's roughly a third of what the same car brings at a dealership. Many of these are insurance vehicles repaired after a collision, so the price reflects that, and it's worth factoring in the cost of any work. But for a buyer willing to do a little homework, it's a genuine path to the world's best-selling EV for a fraction of retail. The savings are real, and they're exactly why more shoppers are looking to the auction lane first.
The Rest Of The Top 5 Are Cars You Already Know
Round out the leaderboard and it reads like a dealership best-seller board. The five most common nameplates over the last three years were:
-
Chevrolet Silverado
-
Toyota Camry
-
Honda Civic
-
Ford F-150
-
Tesla
There's a simple reason the list looks this way. These are the vehicles Americans buy new by the millions, so they're the ones that eventually turn up traded in, off lease, or written off after a fender-bender. The car that sold in huge numbers a decade ago is the car most likely to reach an auction lane today.
Tesla Isn’t The Only EV Crossing The Block
Tesla dominates the electric side of our lanes, but it's no longer alone. Other EVs are showing up too, and they arrive at prices that make a Model Y look expensive:
-
Nissan Leaf — median winning bid around $2,900, with one 2015 example going for just $1,225
-
Chevrolet Bolt — median around $4,500
-
Hyundai Ioniq — median around $4,000
-
We've also had Ford Mustang Mach-E, Kia Niro, Rivian, and even an F-150 Lightning and Equinox EV roll through
The volumes are still small compared to Tesla, which tells you where the used EV market is right now: Tesla built the volume first, so Tesla arrives at auction first. But the rest of the field is following, and for a buyer curious about going electric without paying dealer prices, the entry point keeps getting lower.
Not Old, Not New
The median model year was 2013, which puts the typical auction car right around a decade old. That's the value sweet spot. A ten-year-old car has already shed the steep early depreciation that hits the first owner, but it's modern enough to have airbags, stability control, and years of life left. You skip the new-car premium without buying something on its last legs.
Where These Cars Actually Come From
It helps to know why so many mainstream cars end up on the block in the first place, because the reasons are ordinary, not sinister. Some are lease returns and fleet cars retired on schedule. Some are trade-ins a dealer didn't want to recondition for the front lot. Some are repossessions, and some are insurance vehicles written off after a fender-bender and sold to recover costs. In other words, these cars flow through the same everyday channels that feed the entire used market. The auction is simply the wholesale step most buyers never see, and stepping into it earlier is what unlocks the price difference.
Why You Shouldn't Be Afraid To Buy At Auction
A lot of people assume auctions are only for dealers and insiders, or that everything on the block is a mystery. The data says otherwise. The cars are familiar, the brands are mainstream, and the value is real. A few things work in your favor before you ever place a bid:
- They're easy to research. Reliability, common faults, recalls, and fair pricing are all well documented for a Camry, an F-150, or a Model Y. You can do your homework in the afternoon.
- Parts and mechanics are everywhere. Every shop in the country has worked on these cars, which keeps repairs affordable and predictable.
- They hold their value. Demand for mainstream models never really dries up, so a car you buy smart at auction stays easy to resell later.
- You can check before you commit. Running the VIN and reviewing a car's history turns an unknown into a known quantity, so you always know what you're bidding on.
Put it together and the picture flips. The auction lane isn't a wall of anonymous, risky metal. It's mostly the same trusted cars you'd shop for anyway, at prices well below the dealership, and increasingly it's where the electric cars that felt out of reach finally come within budget. For a buyer willing to look, that's not a risk. It's an opportunity.
View Current Auctions → SCA Auctions
